Powered by Blogger.
RSS
Showing posts with label revising a novel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label revising a novel. Show all posts

Editing: When is Enough, Enough?

          I didn't know what I was going to talk about today as I've been preoccupied with editing my novel and editing on one of the critique forums on the internet. But it was until I saw a girl who said she was about done with her query and wanted to know which version to send out that the idea for what to write today came to me.

          I warned the writer, just like I do every writer who thinks they're done with a piece of work that while ten more people might like it, there will be at least one person who won't and except for a few revisions, she had a pretty solid query. It was much better than what she started out with, and I got a feel for her story. I thought it could get a few bites from agents. But sure enough, a few comments later someone came up with the comment that they didn't like either one, and therefore started a complete overhaul of the query again.

          I can't say it enough. If seven out of ten like it, don't worry about the other three. A writer can't satisfy everyone and a writer can't satisfy every agent. They have different opinions too.

          So when is enough enough? I've been trying to figure it out too as I go through and proofread my novel. The few published authors I communicate with online are saying that you're never truly done until your book is published on a bookshelf somewhere and you can't take it back. That's it. It's done.

          But for those of use who are at least a year or more from publication, when do we know? Well, when we starting changing things back to the way they were before, that's when you know it's time to stop.

          See, there is a fine line between under-editing and over-editing, and when you cross either line you start making sloppy mistakes or do things that don't fit. My suggestion is to pick it up and put it down no more than five or six times. That doesn't include proofreading. But our works will never be perfect and someone will always think it can be improved. So don't worry about the few that don't like it. Focus on the more that like it, if more like it.

          Think of the big names in writing. J.K. Rowling for one. Not everyone likes her book. I mean, there are seven billion people on the planet. But enough of them, definitely not the majority but enough, liked her book and bought it so that she's a billionaire now. So think of it like that.

           We'll never be able to satisfy everyone and we as writers will never be satisfied, but when we feel that we've done all we can and we can do no more because we want to revert it back, that's enough. Live with it and be done. The reader does count, but the writer does too and I think in effort to try to satisfy the readership, we writers forget that.

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS

Wordiness Part Two


            So the last time I talked about wordiness, it was in reference to scenes or paragraph which was what I did in my previous run-through of my novel, which is more so editing since I was taking out huge chunks. But now as I go through the simpler, less frustrating process of proofreading, I want to talk about those words and phrases that make a story wordy.

            The first time I spoke about this, I didn’t go over the phrases and types of words that make a novel or any story wordy. As I’m writing this though, I’m thinking about some of the stuff I read in my Lit class, particularly the stuff that Mary Shelly’s mother wrote. Talk about a modern editor’s nightmare. It’s full of redundancy, superfluous words, and all kinds of stuff that would make me throw a book across the room, but I that was in the Seventeenth century and the woman was trying to prove a point about the intelligence of women.

            In any case, repetitiveness is one of the things that can really cause a novel to be wordy. In my experience and as I was going through my novel, if you look at the beginning of your sentence and the end of your sentence, you may find redundancy. Many times it’s in those phrases like as a matter of fact, though, however, the reason, because of etc. These phrases or things that mean similar things to them or work in the way these phrases do are where I found most of my redundancies because they can be tagged at either the end or beginning of a sentence and sound good.

            I also found redundancies at the end and beginning of paragraphs. I would say something at the beginning of a paragraph and then say it again at the end. That comes from writing essays where I state my topic or thesis at the beginning and then have to restate it at the end. But in novels and in short paragraphs in particular, that isn’t necessary unless you do so on purpose. But many times, you’ll find that you did it unconsciously in trying to make sure you got your point across.

            Another place I found wordiness is in my verbs, particularly in the use of have, has, and had. I would say things like, She had been working all night in places where I could have easily said, She worked all night or She was working all night.  No in all those forms, the way those verbs are used can change that tense or the implication of the verb just slightly. For instance had been working can mean that she worked and is still working, while She worked all night is strictly past tense. But I was using had been or had something when I could have just used the past tense or a phrase that was equally shorter. It usually made for a much smoother read.

            There were also places where I described something and then said it again later. So for instance, in the beginning of my novel, I establish in some way that my character has dark brown hair. So that means I don’t have to say that she has dark brown hair again every time she runs a hand through her hair.

            I also don’t constantly have to remind the reader that someone is beautiful or even waste time on telling what my character is wearing every scene unless it’s relevant to the story. So while it’s not necessary to take all those references out, you don’t need to throw it in the reader’s face either, even if it is relevant.

            Also,  I have to talk about the adverbs. Now I've gotten good with not using those, but I seemed to like these three words a lot: suddenly, abruptly, finally, especially when I got towards the climax and battle scenes. It's not that adverbs are bad, but they usually can be replaced with stronger verbs and if you need an adverb, try using ones that don't end in -ly. In my case, the verbs I had were just fine and needed no adverbs to help build them up. So many of them were cut and those that weren't, I might go cut anyway and find a stronger verb to help.

            So this was just some of the things I observed when I was editing and that I will certainly be on the lookout for as I proofread. But no more tweaking the story thankfully. The story and structure are solid. Not to practice writing queries…

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS

Conquering Burnout


            It’s the end of NaNoWriMo and while many of you are geared up and ready to go at it again, just as many may be burned out. For me it’s the end of school and I’m not burned out, but school has effectively stifled my creative genius. You try writing when you’re not sure how this grade for a test that’s impossible to ace is going to look.

            Anyway, it happens we get burned out either because we’ve been writing too much or life just gets to you. I spoke in this conversation on the absolute write forums (it’s in my blogroll). The writer was just saying how they hate everything they write. They can’t stand it. They start off excited and then it drops off.

            Well let me tell you, being a writer is not an easy thing, especially when it looks like you’ve put so much work into it and you’re not getting anything in return. I know the feeling and when life starts to get to you and people start talking impatient talk about what you’re going to do with your writing or assume that since you major in English you’re going to be a teacher, it can put a damper on your spirits to the point where you hate the craft and aren’t happy with anything because it just isn’t good enough.

            I know. It happened to me. I tried to write and couldn't write, and I stopped writing for a long time just because it looked like things were getting nowhere. My personal solution? I up and decided to write a fanfic one day. Don’t ask me why. I just did and I posted it on the biggest fanfiction site online, fanfiction.net

            There was something rather therapeutic on that. For one, you can get instant gratification in the form of reviews and not just from the people who are going to review a bad story just because their favorite shipping is in it. I got the writers who would do in-depth analysis and critiques and gave me advice to make the story better. I always was one to go against the grain and so I always explored new ideas and execution that others either didn’t think of or rather didn’t have the guts to try because it would be hard to pull off. So as a result, I got a lot of readers. It wasn’t in vain though. I learned a lot from fanfiction

            When you’re dealing with other people’s characters and you’re a perfectionist like me who wants them to stay in character as much as possible while evolving it to fit another role, it takes some careful thinking and imagining the voices in your head and asking “what would this character do?” So I learned a lot about characterization.

            I also managed to develop my style and learn to recognize it. Also, because I’m obsessed with going against the trend, I developed a knack for execution and learned exactly how execution made all the difference.

            I also learned boatloads about editing and proofreading and learned I just have to take it one chapter at a time and edit as thought I’m going to be post my novel on the internet tomorrow.

            So my point is while it seemed frivolous, I was still learning and studying writing, but sometimes it’s good to take a different approach and get some pride back into your writing when you learn you’re not that terrible of a writer at all, you just need the opportunity.

            Now I’m not telling everyone to go write some fanfiction when you burn out or need a break, but what I am saying is find something else to do that related to writing, but not your novel. Enter some contests, get on forums and edit other people’s stuff. Do something where you’re learning about the craft, can rekindle your love for the craft, so that when you’re finally ready to face your writing in a few months, you’ll have new focus and renewed passion.

            Everyone’s outlet won’t be the same, but whatever works for you. Take a year off if that’s what you need. Hope this helped someone. Now off to edit some more.

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS

Wordiness


As I comb through my novel this last final time, I am seriously understanding the meaning of what people say when they say something’s wordy.

All writers have the tendency and something like that is perfectly fine in the first draft, but as I edit, I really see how it drags down the story. The use of adverbs for instance is a common way to find wordiness. Take that sentence right there above that I opened with.

As I comb through my novel this last final time, I am seriously understanding the meaning of what people say when they say something’s wordy.

See how wordy that is. I can get the same effect with fewer words. Mind you, I am habitually wordy on this since it is a blog, but it’s good to know I do know what I’m talking about when I can critique and dissect my own work on the spot. Anyway, let’s revise that.

As I comb through my novel this last final time, I am seriously understanding understand the meaning of what people say when they say what’s meant when people say something’s wordy.

Note that I only corrected some of the wordiness and didn’t put exactly what people. It’s not needed for this lesson. But you can see that we get the same impact. In fact, the impact is better that the original sentence because we don’t have to sort through all those unnecessary words. But not only do I have to look for adverbs, adjectives and other words that weight the sentence down, I have to look for entire scenes and paragraphs that don’t move the story forward.

That doesn’t mean that you don’t go into detail and can’t have paragraphs that go into detail (In fact I may need to incorporate some detail when I run back through for proofreading), but I’m talking about those scenes that are just there for the simple purpose that there are there and since I’m working with an old manuscript, there are a lot of them. So you have to ask yourself, does this scene really belong here and it hurts to do for I had some really witty lines in some of the scenes I wrote, but the story was better in the long run.

Now this will seriously hurt your word count, as so far I’m minus about a thousand words, but that’s much less than the last edit which means I probably got it all. I’m looking at going from 72k to 65k, which is fine. It may become more because I will definitely add more detail as I reread it for flow and clarity, but the good thing about trimming in writing is that you don’t have to wait for it to grow back like you do when trimming a bush. If you think you trimmed too much, go back to the other version.

So I just felt like writing this as I come to the end of editing my novel. Can’t wait to be finished. I’m still not sure if I’m going to query agents or self-publish as an e-book, but I’ll see. Hope this helped someone to know that they’re not alone. This veteran amateur is doing some of the same things you are right now.

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • RSS